SHRM Opposes California Bill with Blanket Employer Wage Penalty

SHRM has expressed its opposition to California Assembly Bill 1234, introduced by Assemblymember Liz Ortega. The bill proposes a major overhaul of the labor commissioner’s wage claim process, introducing new financial penalties for employers, regardless of fault or intent. While SHRM advocates for the strong enforcement of wage and labor laws, it believes this bill’s disproportionate penalties could hurt employers operating in good faith.  

Under AB 1234, a mandatory 30% administrative penalty would automatically apply to every order, decision, or award the labor commissioner issues — even before any appeal or judicial review can take place. According to SHRM, this blanket penalty would impose a significant financial burden on employers who may simply be exercising their right to due process, particularly in cases where the facts are uncertain or liability is ambiguous. Such a framework discourages legitimate defenses and could dissuade employers from seeking clarity or fairness in disputed claims. READ MORE